Showing posts with label Civil. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Civil. Show all posts

Monday, November 9, 2026

Wedding Bell Blues

The other day as I was out and about, I ran into a buddy of mine who had only recently proposed to his girlfriend of 2 years.

Happy, happy are they and their respective parents.  As part of the proposal, Guy went out and bought Girl a 2 caret diamond ring (a real diamond) which set him back $30,500.  The plan was to be married in December with a March engagement.  So, they had 9 months to get ready.

 
I'm thinking 9 months to get ready?  That's a long time.  Heck, a whole lot of not good things can happen in 9 months.  Annnnnnnnnd, turns out I was right as Guy found out only recently that Girl has been unfaithful multiple times.  

Now, Guy wants out (i.e. break the engagement) AND Guy wants the ring back but Girl is resisting.  I mean, it is a nice ring.  

Question:  Can Guy get the ring back?

Short answer is yes,...well, maybe...unless a specific state rule or fact pattern changes the outcome.

See, engagement rings are typically treated as a “conditional gift.”  A conditional gift is a gift in which the donor’s (i.e. the person who gave the gift) intent to transfer ownership depends on the occurrence of a specified event.  If the condition is not satisfied, the donor retains the right to recover the property.

Here, the condition was marriage actually occurring (not just being engaged).  If the marriage doesn’t happen, the condition fails and ring must be returned.

So under the dominant modern rule:  No wedding = no completed gift and the donor (Guy) gets the ring back.

Pretty straight forward, right?  Eh, sometimes.

And as this is a legal-esque blog, I got to wondering what areas of law are we dealing with here?
 

A.  Gift Law (Property)

When courts say an engagement ring is a conditional gift, they are really answering a property question.  Specifically, courts are asking who has title (ownership), and when does ownership fully transfer?

This is not just semantics.  Title determines who has the right to possess, keep, or recover the item.  In property law, a valid gift normally requires:

  1. Donative intent (something is given without expecting anything in return.)
  2. Delivery
  3. Acceptance

If all three are satisfied, title transfers immediately and completely. A conditional gift, however, changes the giver's donative intent.  

So, instead of saying here is a gift, now it's yours, when a condition is involved, this means is that a person gives a gift because they want to, but the other person (i.e the receiver of the gift) must do what was asked to keep it. 

In the case of an engagement, title is NOT fully transferred at delivery.  Instead, the law treats the transfer like this:
 

Stage 1: Delivery (Engagement)

  • Recipient gets possession
  • BUT ownership is defeasible

Defeasible means something is valid or allowed now, but it can be taken away or ended if something happens (or does not happen). Think of it as a provisional ownership interest subject to being undone if a/the condition does not occur.

Stage 2: Condition Occurs (Marriage)

In this instance, title becomes absolute and the gift is now irrevocable (he can't take the ring back).
 

Stage 3: Condition Fails (No Marriage)

Because donor (Guy) and donee (Girl) were not married, title is never fully vested in the donee (Girl), and the law treats the donor (Guy) as having retained superior ownership.  The result here is that Guy can reclaim the ring (i.e. his property). 

 

B.  Contract Principles (but limited)

An engagement is not an enforceable contract to marry.  What this means is that even if two people agree to get married, the law will not force them to go through with the marriage or punish them just for backing out.

 

In order for a contract to exist, there must be an offer, acceptance, and consideration.  In an engagement scenario, courts still analogize that a ring acts as consideration-like inducement for marriage.

 

What "consideration-like inducement for marriage" means is that the ring functions similar to consideration in contract law; it’s something given to encourage (induce) the other person to go through with the marriage but it’s not legally enforceable consideration. 

 

So, while the ring resembles consideration because it’s given in exchange for the expected marriage, since the promise to marry isn’t legally enforceable, courts treat it as a conditional gift instead of a true contract exchange. 

 

C.  Restitution / Unjust Enrichment

If recipient keeps ring after condition fails, they would be unjustly enriched.  In this case where Guy gave Girl a ring on condition of marriage, the only remedy is the return of the ring or its value (i.e. $30,500).
 

D.  Family Law Overlay

Courts try to stay out of people’s personal relationship drama and avoid deciding who behaved badly....unless a law specifically requires them to.
 
So, to that, 
California Civil Code § 1590
governs the return of gifts, such as engagement rings, made in contemplation of marriage. If the recipient refuses to marry or the engagement is broken by mutual consent, the donor may recover the ring or its value.  If the donor breaks the engagement, the recipient often keeps it. 

As this applies to our set of facts:

  • Girl cheated, she is “at fault”
  • Guy calls off wedding due to infidelity

Guy likely gets ring back

Under Simonian v. Donoian, 96 Cal. App. 2d 259, 215 P.2d 119 (1939), the court found that a donor can recover their property (i.e. the ring) if the marriage does not occur unless donor is at fault.  

Further, in Shaw v. Shaw, 35 Cal. App. 3d 648, 111 Cal. Rptr. 398 (1972), the court held that gifts given in contemplation of marriage are recoverable under §1590 which reinforces the statutory framework rather than relying on pure common law.

However, there are a number of opinions that suggest that Girl can keep the ring.  

For example, in Albinger v. Harris, 48 P.3d 711 (Mont. 2002) the Montana Supreme Court rejected the conditional-gift rule for engagement rings and held that an engagement ring was given without any express or implied condition of marriage, and under Montana gift law, once delivered and accepted, the ring was a completed, irrevocable gift that could not be revoked simply because the engagement ended.

In North Dakota, courts have also treated engagement rings as unconditional gifts.  In Kohler v. Flynn, 493 N.W.2d 647 (N.D. 1992), the court held that the recipient of an engagement ring can keep the ring even if no marriage occurs.

Finally, Virginia abolished “heart balm” lawsuits under Virginia Code § 8.01-220 and now frequently refers to trial court level cases like Georgalas v. Kilgore, 73 Va. Cir. 34, 2006 Va. Cir. LEXIS 292 (Va. Cir. Ct. 2006) which held that treating the ring as conditional would revive a breach-of-promise-type claim.  Consequently, Virginia courts refuse to order return of an engagement ring. 

I guess the moral to this story is that an engagement ring is basically a “we’re getting married” deposit.  If the wedding never happens, most courts will hand it back to the person who paid for it. 

However, just be aware (and depending on the jurisdiction you're in), the legal system may either ignore who caused the breakup entirely or quietly side-eye the situation and ask who changed the plans first.

So, maybe the better course of action is to really, REALLY be sure your betrothed is THE one.  

Well, that or just make sure the jurisdiction where you're getting engaged (not just where you're getting married) favors the giver of the ring OR maybe hold off buying that $30K ring until after the wedding.

Renewed vows, anyone?! 



Monday, October 19, 2026

Legal Myth Monday: The Myths and Realities of Trespass

Trespass rarely arrives wearing a black mask and carrying a sack marked “PROPERTY RIGHTS.” 

Sometimes it looks like a neighbor's fence, a shortcut across the yard, a wayward dog, or even a puff of smoke drifting across the property line.

Behind these deceptively innocent intrusions lurks a surprisingly complex body of law and the myths are everywhere.

So, today, we're going to explore all things Trespass so that you don't get crossed up (or crossed over) where you ought not be. 

Myth #1: “If there’s not a No Trespassing sign posted, it isn’t trespassing.”

Reality: A sign is useful evidence of lack of permission, but civil trespass does not generally depend upon a sign.

Authority:  State v. Christensen, 131 Idaho 143, 953 P.2d 583, 587–88 (1998).

Christensen involved law enforcement entering private property during an investigation. The property owner argued that a “No Trespassing” sign demonstrated that the officers had no implied license to enter.

The Idaho Supreme Court recognized that a clearly posted “No Trespassing” sign, particularly when combined with a physical barrier such as a gate, can revoke the ordinary implied license to approach a residence. The court contrasted that situation with circumstances in which the property owner has not clearly manifested an intent to exclude visitors.

Reality Check:  A sign is a warning, not a magic spell. Your property doesn't suddenly become trespass-proof only after somebody hammers up a piece of plywood saying “KEEP OUT.” 

Myth #2: “You have to intend to trespass.”

Reality: You generally have to intend the physical entry, but you do not have to intend to violate someone else's property rights.

Authority:  Ansay v. Boecking-Berry Equip. Co., 450 F.2d 433, 435–36 (10th Cir. 1971).

The case involved an unlawful possession of land and whether the defendant's good-faith belief that its legal position was correct should protect it from trespass liability or reduce the damages.

The Tenth Circuit held that the defendant's state of mind was generally irrelevant to the trespass claim. The required intent was simply the intent to perform the act that resulted in the entry. Thus, a person can be liable even when acting in good faith and under a reasonable—but mistaken—belief that the entry is lawful.

Reality Check:  “But I thought it was my property!” is not automatically a Get-Out-of-Trespass-Free card. 

Myth #3: “If I accidentally cross the property line, I can't be liable for trespass.”

Reality: An innocent mistake about the boundary does not necessarily defeat the underlying trespass claim.

Authority:  Fischer v. Croston, 164 Idaho 189, 438 P.3d 1211 (2019).

This was a boundary dispute between neighboring landowners. The parties disagreed about ownership of a strip of property. One side entered the disputed property, removed vegetation, and constructed a fence. The defendants argued that their conduct was based on their belief concerning the boundary.

The Idaho Supreme Court explained that an innocent mistake concerning the boundary or location of property can matter to trespass liability and damages, but it distinguished that situation from conduct occurring after the defendant has been put on notice that the property is disputed. 

Once the defendants knew of the dispute and nevertheless reentered, cut vegetation, and erected the fence, the court found the conduct willful and intentional and upheld trespass liability and treble damages.

Reality Check:  Your surveyor may be wrong. Your GPS may be wrong. Your memory may definitely be wrong. The property line doesn't care. 

Myth #4: “If I didn't damage anything, there is no trespass.”

Reality: Physical damage isn't required.

Authority: Walker Drug Co. v. La Sal Oil Co., 972 P.2d 1238, 1243–44 (Utah 1998).

The Utah Supreme Court considered trespass and the damages associated with an invasion of possessory rights.

Trespass protects the right to exclusive possession. Proof of actual damage is not necessary to establish liability; damages can include nominal damages where substantial damages aren't shown.

Reality Check:  You don't have to bulldoze the rose garden. Sometimes the trespass is the damage. 

Myth #5: “Trespass only happens when a person physically walks onto someone else's property.”

Reality: A trespass can occur when a person causes another person or a thing to enter the land.

Authority:  Pub. Serv. Co. of Colo. v. Van Wyk, 27 P.3d 377, 389–90 (Colo. 2001).

The plaintiffs alleged that emissions from the defendant's electrical transmission operations crossed onto their property. The Colorado Supreme Court addressed whether trespass requires the defendant, or a tangible object, to physically enter the property.

The court explained that traditional trespass involves a physical intrusion, and that the Restatement recognizes liability where the defendant “causes a thing or third person” to enter another's land. The court then went further and held that, under Colorado law, intangible intrusions can also constitute trespass when they satisfy the applicable requirements.

Reality Check:  Your feet aren't required. Your trash can, dirt pile, fence, equipment or anything else you intentionally put over the line can do the trespassing for you. 

Myth #6: “If I built the fence on the wrong side of the property line by mistake, that's not trespass.”

Reality: It can be.

Authority:  La Bruno v. Lawrence, 64 N.J. Super. 570, 166 A.2d 163, 166–68 (App. Div. 1960).

A surveyor mistakenly located the boundary between neighboring properties. Relying on the erroneous survey, the neighboring property owners had a fence constructed on the plaintiff's property. The plaintiff sued for trespass and damages.

The New Jersey Appellate Division held that the surveyor's mistake, honest belief, or professional negligence was not a defense to the underlying trespass. The court did, however, distinguish between trespass liability and punitive damages: the mistake could negate the intentional wrongdoing necessary for punitive damages.

Reality Check:  “Oops” is a perfectly good explanation of how the fence got there. It isn't necessarily a legal defense to leaving it there. 

Myth #7: “Trespass requires malicious or bad-faith conduct.”

Reality: No. Malice or bad faith may become important when determining punitive damages, but they're not necessary for basic trespass liability.

Authority:  Miller v. National Broadcasting Co., 187 Cal. App. 3d 1463, 1477–78, 232 Cal. Rptr. 668 (1986).

NBC's camera crew entered the plaintiff's apartment without authorization while investigating a story. The trial court had concluded that there was no trespass because the defendants lacked malice and the plaintiff suffered no actual damage.

The California Court of Appeal rejected that reasoning. The court explained that trespass is an intentional tort in the legal sense because the defendants intended to enter the property. Their particular motivation (whether malicious, innocent, or otherwise) was not necessary to establish trespass. The court specifically distinguished the intent required for trespass from the state of mind that might justify punitive damages.

Reality Check:  You don't have to be a villainous villain twirling a mustache. Sometimes you're just a trespassing trespasser. 

Myth #8: “Only the person who owns the property can sue for trespass.”

Reality: Trespass is fundamentally a possessory action. Ownership and possession are not necessarily the same thing.

Authority:  Manor Enterprises, Inc. v. Vivid, Inc., 228 Wis. 2d 59, 596 N.W.2d 425 (Ct. App. 1999).

The case involved a dispute over unauthorized placement of objects on property. The defendant challenged the plaintiff's ability to maintain a trespass action.

The Wisconsin Court of Appeals expressly stated that a plaintiff in a trespass action need establish only a right to possession of the land, not ownership of the land. In other words, trespass protects the possessory interest.

Reality Check:  Trespass law protects possession, not just whoever has the prettiest deed in the filing cabinet. 

Myth #9: “Once you give someone permission to enter your property, they can keep coming back.”

Reality: Consent has boundaries. Permission can be limited, revoked, or exceeded.

Authority: Restatement (Second) of Torts § 158 (Am. L. Inst. 1965)

Keyzer v. Amerlink, Ltd., 173 N.C. App. 736, 620 S.E.2d 511 (2005).

The case involved a dispute over entry onto property where the defendants claimed they had permission to enter. The North Carolina Court of Appeals examined the nature and limits of consent to enter another person's land.

The court explained that consent to enter another's property is conditional, not absolute. A person who initially enters with permission can become a trespasser by subsequently exceeding or abusing the scope of that permission. The court relied on Blackwood v. Cates, 297 N.C. 163, 167, 254 S.E.2d 7, 9 (1979), for the principle that an initially lawful entry can become trespass when the entrant's subsequent conduct exceeds the authority granted.

Reality Check:  “Come over anytime” is not the same thing as “Congratulations, you've acquired a lifetime easement.” 

Myth #10: “If the public has traditionally used private land, that automatically gives the public a legal right to use it.”

Reality: Longstanding use does not automatically create a public easement.

Authority:  Clickner v. Magothy River Ass'n, 424 Md. 253, 35 A.3d 464 (2012).

The case involved Dobbins Island, where members of the public had historically used a beach on privately owned property. The public had used the beach for years, and the question was whether that longstanding use had created a legal right to continue using the private property.

The Maryland Court of Appeals held that the public's historic use did not automatically establish a public easement or right of access. The court applied a presumption that public use was permissive rather than adverse. Because the evidence did not establish that the public had used the property under a claim of right, the use remained a revocable license, which the owners could terminate.

Reality Check:  “Because we've always done it” might work at a family reunion, it's considerably less impressive in a property dispute. 

Myth #11: “If my neighbor lets me use part of his property long enough, I automatically get an easement.”

Reality: Permission and adverse use are fundamentally different concepts. Long use does not automatically create a property right.

Authority:  Workman v. Klinkenberg, 4 Wn. App. 2d 981, 430 P.3d 716, 721–23 (2018).

The dispute concerned a claimed prescriptive easement over neighboring property. The claimant argued that his long use of the property entitled him to an easement.

The Washington Court of Appeals held that when use of another person's property begins as a neighborly accommodation, the person claiming a prescriptive easement must overcome the presumption that the use was permissive. The claimant must show when and how the use became adverse. Simply continuing to use the property doesn't automatically transform permission into a property right.

Reality Check:  Ten years of your neighbor saying “Sure, go ahead” doesn't necessarily mean you now own a piece of his driveway. 

Myth #12: “If I genuinely need to cross someone's property, necessity makes it legal.”

Reality: Necessity can be a recognized defense or can support certain property doctrines, but “I really needed to” isn't a universal trespass exemption.

Authority: Restatement (Second) of Torts § 197 (Am. L. Inst. 1965) 

Ploof v. Putnam, 81 Vt. 471, 71 A. 188, 190 (1908).

Ploof was sailing on Lake Champlain when a violent storm arose. He sought refuge by mooring his boat to the defendant's dock. The defendant's servant untied the boat, causing it to be driven ashore and damaged.

The Vermont Supreme Court held that necessity can justify what would otherwise be a trespass. When a person reasonably enters another's property to escape an imminent danger, the entry can be privileged. The court therefore rejected the argument that the plaintiff's entry onto the private dock was simply an unlawful trespass.

Reality Check:  “I was taking a shortcut” and “I was escaping a life-threatening emergency” are not exactly the same legal argument. 

Myth #13: “If someone is trespassing, the property owner can do whatever is necessary to remove them.”

Reality: The right to exclude trespassers does not give a landowner unlimited authority to use force.

Authority: Restatement (Second) of Torts §§ 77–83 (Am. L. Inst. 1965):  The common-law privilege of reasonable self-help is limited by the circumstances and applicable state law.

Saidi v. United States, 110 A.3d 606, 611–12 (D.C. 2015).

Saidi was charged with assault after he punched a man who refused to leave an apartment. Saidi claimed he was justified in using force to eject a trespasser and protect his property.

The D.C. Court of Appeals recognized that a person lawfully in possession of real property has a common-law privilege to use a reasonable amount of force to eject a trespasser. But that privilege ends when the force used exceeds what is reasonably necessary under the circumstances. The court upheld Saidi's conviction because the evidence supported the conclusion that his use of force was not justified.

Reality Check:  “Get off my lawn” is property law. “And now I'm going to beat you with a baseball bat” is a completely different legal seminar. 

Myth #14: “If I don't know the property line, I can't be liable for trespass.”

Reality: Lack of knowledge of the boundary is not necessarily a defense to the underlying trespass.

Authority:   Barrios v. Simpkins, No. M2021-01347-COA-R3-CV, 2022 WL 16846642 (Tenn. Ct. App. Nov. 10, 2022).

Neighboring landowners disputed the location of their common boundary. The trial court established the boundary but dismissed the trespass claim because the defendants believed the disputed property belonged to them.

The Tennessee Court of Appeals held that the defendants' belief that they owned the property did not eliminate the intent required for trespass. The relevant intent was the intent to be on the land; the defendants' subjective belief concerning ownership was irrelevant to that element. The trespass claim was therefore remanded for further proceedings.

Reality Check:  The law doesn't require you to carry a surveyor's transit in your backpack. Unfortunately, it also doesn't require the boundary to announce itself when you cross it. 

Myth #15: “Civil trespass means the defendant was negligent.”

Reality:  Here's the head-spinner: trespass is generally an intentional tort, but the defendant doesn't have to intend the damage or even realize the act will invade someone else's property. The relevant intent can be simply intending to perform the act that produces the intrusion (ie walking across the property line).

Authority:  Hoery v. United States, 64 P.3d 214, 217–18 (Colo. 2003).

The case involved claims arising from government activities that allegedly caused an intrusion onto private property. The Colorado Supreme Court examined the intent requirement for trespass and distinguished intentional trespass from negligence.

The court held that trespass requires an intent to perform the act that itself constitutes, or inevitably causes, the intrusion. The defendant does not have to intend to cause the resulting damage. Colorado therefore treats trespass as an intentional tort rather than simply another form of negligence.

Reality Check:  “I accidentally did it” may save you from one tort while leaving you standing squarely in another.

The bottom line here is that trespass law isn't about who crossed the line with the most nefarious intentions  Sometimes, you can be trespassing without even realizing you've crossed that line.  While the law draws the line it, unfortunately, doesn't always paint it bright yellow.

 


Monday, August 17, 2026

An Ounce of Prevention

Have you ever had those moments when you thought to yourself - dang, what I should have said was....  Or maybe you did something and later wished you hadn't.

Maybe like when your boss said something condescending to you and at the time the only thing you thought to say was, "That's a good one, boss" then later you thought, what I should have said was "I came here to do good work—not absorb bad management!"

Or maybe when you asked your wife if she minds that you go golfing with your buddies and she says that's "fine" - so you go and when you get back she's pissed off seven ways from Sunday but you don't know why.

Stuff like that.

This got me to thinking the other day when a friend of mine related an interaction he had with a local "Karen" in his neighborhood.  Seems said "Karen" had been riding his backside for the last few months because his Christmas light were still up.

Thing is, there are any number of reasons "Karen's" go off on people but it got me thinking of ways to avoid confrontational neighborhood "Karens."  So, I create a list of ways to keep your neighborhood Susan's or Jennifer's or Laurie's from turning into a Karen.

1. Make your property “boringly compliant”

Most neighbor conflicts come down to things that look like violations—even if they aren’t.  “Make your property ‘boringly compliant’” means keeping everything so clearly within local rules and neighborhood norms that there’s nothing for anyone to latch onto or argue about.  For instance:

  • Keep lawns, weeds, trash bins, and parking tidy
  • Check your city’s basic ordinances (noise hours, fence height, parking rules)
  • If something looks borderline, assume someone will notice

This isn’t about surrender—it’s about removing easy ammunition.

Related Authority:

Village of Belle Terre v. Boraas, 416 U.S. 1 (1974) reinforced the authority of municipalities to establish and enforce land-use regulations. NOTE: the standards come from the ordinance, not the loudest neighbor.

 2. Control the first impression

People are far less likely to escalate if they see you as human.  “Control the first impression” means making sure neighbors see you as a normal, reasonable, low-drama person early on—because people tend to interpret everything you do later through that initial lens.  This can be accomplished by:

  • A simple wave or quick introduction early on goes a long way
  • You don’t need to be friends—just recognizable and polite
  • Avoid coming off defensive or standoffish right out of the gate

It’s harder to complain about “that guy” if you’ve already humanized yourself.

Related Authority:

Prah v. Maretti, 108 Wis. 2d 223, 321 N.W.2d 182 (1982) recognized that neighboring landowners owe one another duties of reasonable use and that disputes between neighbors should be evaluated in light of what is reasonable under the circumstances.

3. Don’t feed the escalation loop

“Don’t feed the escalation loop” means resisting the urge to match someone’s intensity when they come at you with complaints, attitude, or accusations. The more emotion, defensiveness, or sarcasm you add, the more the interaction tends to spiral.  If someone nitpicks or complains:

  • Stay calm, brief, and neutral
  • Don’t argue on the sidewalk—it turns into theater
  • If they’re wrong, you don’t need to prove it immediately

Escalation is oxygen. Starve it.

Related Authority:

In Rattigan v. Wile, 445 Mass. 850, 841 N.E.2d 680 (2006), a disagreement between neighbors escalated into a deliberate campaign of retaliation that ultimately resulted in liability for private nuisance. The legal lesson is simple: once a dispute becomes about "getting even" instead of solving the problem, every retaliatory act increases the likelihood that a judge (not just the neighbors) will become involved.

4. Use quiet documentation

Keep a calm, private record of what’s happening instead of reacting in the moment or getting pulled into arguments.  The point isn’t to build a case theatrically; it’s to create clarity and protection for yourself if things escalate.  If someone is persistently difficult:

  • Keep records (dates, what happened, photos if relevant)
  • Save texts or written communication
  • Know your HOA or city complaint process before you need it

This flips the power dynamic without confrontation.

Related Authority:

Courts recognize that memories fade, stories change, and disputes become harder to resolve as time passes. Contemporaneous records—such as photographs, messages, logs, and written observations—can be powerful evidence because they capture events closer to the time they occurred. See United States v. Orr, 68 F.3d 1247, 1251–52 (10th Cir. 1995).

5. Choose your battles (strategically)

Recognize that not every annoyance, comment, or minor rule-bending is worth your time, energy, or reputation to confront.  The strategic part is deciding what actually has long-term impact: safety issues, repeated harassment, property damage, or whether formal violations are worth addressing.  So:

  • Minor annoyance → let it go
  • Pattern of harassment or false complaints → address formally
  • Safety or legal issues → act immediately

Winning every small fight can lose you the bigger war.  What this means is that a person who complains about everything risks looking unreasonable, but a person who ignores a pattern of escalating conduct may lose the ability to prove the seriousness of the problem later. The strategic choice is not "never complain"; it is reserve formal action for things that have legal or practical consequences.

Related Authority:

The law recognizes that neighbors will inevitably annoy each other from time to time. Courts generally distinguish between ordinary inconveniences and conduct that creates a substantial interference with property rights. See Armstrong v. Francis Corp., 20 N.J. 320, 120 A.2d 4 (1956). 

6. Set calm boundaries

Clearly define what behavior you will and won’t engage with, but you do it without anger, lectures, or emotional escalation.  In practice, this looks like short, repeatable statements.  You stay consistent—calmly reinforcing the same limit if needed.  If someone crosses a line:

  • “I’m happy to follow city rules, but I’m not going to engage beyond that.”
  • Repeat as needed, without adding emotion

Consistency beats clever comebacks.

Related Authority:

In Rowan v. United States Post Office Department, 397 U.S. 728 (1970), the Supreme Court upheld a homeowner's right to stop unwanted communications from entering the home. The practical lesson is simple: state the boundary clearly, avoid unnecessary debate, and do not turn every disagreement into a confrontation. 

7. Build a buffer (social proof)

Quietly create a network of normal, neutral, or positive neighbor relationships so you’re not isolated or easy to target if conflict ever pops up.  This is important because neighborhood disputes often aren’t just about facts; they’re about perception and who seems credible.  If you have even one or two neutral-to-positive neighbors:

  • Casual friendliness creates a “baseline reputation”
  • People are less likely to side against someone who seems reasonable

It’s subtle, but powerful.

Related Authority:

Credibility, reputation, and perception matter when evaluating disputed claims. In Bose Corp. v. Consumers Union of United States, Inc., 466 U.S. 485 (1984), the SCOTUS discussed the importance of reputation and the difficulty of determining truth when competing accounts exist.

8. Worst-case: disengage + formal channels

Recognize when direct, informal interaction has stopped being productive and switching to a more structured, low-contact approach is a better approach.  If someone is truly relentless:

  • Stop direct interaction
  • Communicate only in writing if necessary
  • Use HOA, mediation, or local code enforcement appropriately

At that point, it’s not about winning socially—it’s about protecting your time and sanity.

Related Authority:

Courts recognize that when disputes become persistent and informal efforts fail, the solution is often a structured remedy - not more arguing. See Boomer v. Atlantic Cement Co., 26 N.Y.2d 219, 309 N.Y.S.2d 312, 257 N.E.2d 870 (1970).  Also, in Rondeau v. Mosinee Paper Corp., 422 U.S. 49 (1975) the SCOTUS discussed the availability of equitable relief when legal rights require structured judicial intervention.

The thing is, most people want to be reasonable.  Rare is the case that people flip out over kids playing in the street, or neighbors having a block party, or someone installing a pool in their backyard.

While most people want to be reasonable, some don't.  In such cases, keep a record, take notes, make friends where you can and, maybe, just maybe, buy one of those REALLY loud 1,000 watt speakers to blast Mozart's Queen of the Night aria at at all hours of the day/night and engage in some serious psychological warfare.

 


I mean, if Karen wants crazy, I suggest going lunatic crazy.  

Go all out.  

Make a scene.  

Give as good as you get.  

It may be counterintuitive, but sometimes crazy is good for the soul.

 

 

Monday, August 10, 2026

Disposable Income

Do you have more money than you know what to do with?  I know a few people like that.  I knew a guy who bought and traded twin-engine planes like most kids trade baseball cards. 

The thing is that people will buy what they want to buy not necessarily what they need to buy.

Recently, I became a card-carrying member of Costco.  Consequently, each week I get an email message from my friendly neighborhood Costco telling me about all the lovely thing I could buy - not things I value or want but someone apparently does.

This week, I got a notice about one such item that caught my attention called La Prairie Skill Caviar Liquid Lift.  Sounds French - which, to be fair, isn't a bad thing - it's just a thing....an expensive thing.  

Anyway, most times when I get these emails, it says how much the thing costs. What caught my attention was that there was no price attached to La Prairie Skill Caviar Liquid Lift which piqued my interest and got me to doing some investigating.

According to the official La Prairie website:

The new Skin Caviar Liquid Lift is augmented with Caviar Micro-Nutrients to help support skin's metabolism for augmented lifting efficacy. Day after day, wrinkles and lines appear faded, skin is firmed and youthful contours are revealed.

Sounds like fancy make-up.  Turns out, La Prairie Skill Caviar Liquid Lift costs an astounding $785 (USD) for a 50 ml/1.7 oz bottle.  

For $785, I'd want someone to come apply the stuff personally!  That's the thing, though.  While I can't see spending that much cash for something I can't even eat, other people clearly will and do.


The reason I'm bringing this all up is because I was talking to someone I met on the street.  Person was standing next to his spanking brand new Chevrolet Stingray Corvette 3LT Convertible. 

It was beautiful.

In the course of our conversation, Person noted that they were looking to provide for their family in case of their demise and was wondering to me whether they should get a will or a living trust.

According to Google, a living will outlines your medical preferences if you become incapacitated - essentially a durable power of attorney.  It addresses end-of-life medical care, such as the use of life support, pain management, and organ donation

A living trust, on the other hand, manages and distributes your assets during your lifetime and after your death allowing you to bypass probate (a costly legal process of distributing assets after death) and ensures your assets are distributed according to your instructions.

Believe it or don't, there are a whole lot of people in legal land who will say they can help you at low cost.  Popular legal website Rocket Lawyer says they'll help you create a trust.  Popular publisher Nolo Press has resources that can help you create a generic trust.  However (and I say this from experience working for an estate planning attorney), nothing beats the confidence knowing that you had a lawyer create your trust/will. 

I can't count the number of people we had to bail out in probate court either because their deceased didn't leave a will or the documents they did have were defective and were tossed by the probate judge.  Sometimes there was a trust but, for whatever reason, the trust was never properly funded and their heirs wound up in probate.

Anyway, I suggested Person take a look at Martindale.com to help locate a reputable estate planning attorney.  Aaaaaand that's about where the conversation fell apart.  

Seems Person was really into his money and wasn't really interested in spending money FOR a trust or a will.  Person was just looking for a way to protect his cash for his loved ones without spending any money or the least amount of money possible.

Yeah, it didn't make sense to me but who am I to argue with someone who was wearing a down payment on a house and driving an $185,000 vehicle? 

Thing is, we all decide what we value and what we're willing to spend our money on.  Person liked expensive things but clearly didn't value legal assistance as much as he (or his heirs) probably should (or will).

Monday, July 27, 2026

It's a National Sport in Some States

I've lived on the west coast, the east coast, up north, and down south in the great country that is America.

The one thing that I've found in most any state is that many (no, make that most) people who drive love to tailgate.  Heck in Utah, it's a national sport.

For reference sake, Tailgating = driving too close behind another vehicle without maintaining a safe stopping distance.  Most statutes define it as failing to leave sufficient space “so as to be able to stop safely without colliding.”

When I took driver training in high school many moons ago, "safe stopping distance" meant 2 car lengths or 2 seconds behind the car in front of you (whichever is greater).  Note, that's car lengths like about how long a typical sedan is - not how long a "smart" car is (which is, essentially, a roller skate).

However, according to the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA), National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), State Departments of Motor Vehicles (DMV), Department of Transportation (DOT), National Safety Council (NSC), and every single Insurance provider,  "safe stopping distance" equates to:

  • The Three-Second Rule: This is the most common guideline for passenger vehicles in ideal conditions. You should count three seconds from the time the vehicle in front of you passes a fixed object (like a road sign) until your vehicle passes the same point.
  • Expanded Rules: Driving experts recommend extending the following distance in certain situations:
    • In poor weather (rain, snow): Increase your following distance to four to six seconds or more.
    • At night or with low visibility: Leave extra space for your reaction time.
    • With larger or heavier vehicles: Increase your following distance, as more weight increases the braking distance.
    • On slippery surfaces (ice): Give yourself 10 times the normal braking distance

Essentially, "safe stopping distance is based on the road surface at the point and time you are driving your vehicle.

Maybe the reason people love to tailgate is because they don't know or realize what the danger is?  Tailgating is dangerous because:

  • Reduced reaction time – You can’t stop fast enough if the car ahead brakes suddenly.

  • Rear-end collisions – One of the most common types of crashes, is often caused by tailgating.

  • Chain-reaction crashes – On highways, tailgating leads to multi-car pileups.

  • Aggressive driving risk – Often linked with road rage, intimidation, or reckless driving.

I remember one time I was driving up the I-5 north just past the Tejon Pass and dropped into a swamp of fog 100 miles long up through the San Joaquin Valley (the bread basket of California).  I mean, you couldn't see 3 feet in front of you.  Cars were reduced from driving 55-100 MPH to a measly 3-5 mph.  

Well, most people.  

There was one idiot who was honking and hugging everyone's bumper like the fog was our fault.  We found him a couple miles up the road wrapped around the rear axle of a semi truck.

The thing is, tailgating is a crime in every state of the union.  For example:

California – Cal. Vehicle Code § 21703: Drivers “shall not follow another vehicle more closely than is reasonable and prudent.”

Texas – Tex. Transp. Code § 545.062: Must maintain “assured clear distance.”

New York – N.Y. Veh. & Traf. Law § 1129(a): Must not follow more closely than is “reasonable and prudent.”

Florida – Fla. Stat. § 316.0895: Prohibits following more closely than is reasonable.

Illinois – 625 ILCS 5/11-710: Cannot follow “more closely than is reasonable and prudent.”

Pennsylvania – 75 Pa. Cons. Stat. § 3310: Drivers shall not follow more closely than reasonable.

Ohio – Ohio Rev. Code § 4511.34: “Assured clear distance” and prohibits following too closely.

Michigan – Mich. Comp. Laws § 257.643: Must not follow closer than is “reasonable and prudent.”

Georgia – O.C.G.A. § 40-6-49: Following too closely prohibited.

Arizona – Ariz. Rev. Stat. § 28-730: Must not follow too closely for speed, traffic, and road conditions.

Washington – RCW 46.61.145: Drivers shall not follow “more closely than is reasonable and prudent.”

Colorado – Colo. Rev. Stat. § 42-4-1008: Prohibits following more closely than reasonable.

Virginia – Va. Code § 46.2-816: Following too closely prohibited.

North Carolina – N.C. Gen. Stat. § 20-152: Prohibits following more closely than is reasonable and prudent.

Massachusetts – Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 90, § 14B: Must not follow more closely than is reasonable. 

Utah - Utah Code, Title 41 § 41-6a-711 (Following too closely): The operator of a vehicle may not follow another vehicle more closely than is reasonable and prudent, having due regard for the speed of the vehicles, the traffic upon, and the condition of the highway. 

Wait, what does "reasonable and prudent" mean?  The phrase “reasonable and prudent” is the key standard in almost every state’s tailgating statute. It’s intentionally flexible, because lawmakers can’t write a one-size-fits-all “exact number of feet” that works at every speed and in every road condition.

Like I said up above, when a statute says you must not follow more closely than is “reasonable and prudent”, it means:

  • You must leave enough space to stop safely if the car ahead slows or stops suddenly.

  • The space must adjust based on:

    • Speed (faster = more stopping distance)

    • Traffic density (congested traffic = more caution)

    • Road conditions (wet, icy, or gravel roads require more distance)

    • Vehicle size/weight (trucks need more braking distance than cars)

Legislatures avoid setting a specific distance (like “100 feet”) because safe following distance changes constantly. Instead, “reasonable and prudent” makes it a case-by-case standard, enforced by officers, judges, and juries.

Got that?  It's to the cops discretion whether you were tailgating.

So, if the cop says you were driving too close, you probably were.  Don't argue the issue because you'll just wind up in cuffs with a resisting arrest charge tacked on for your efforts.  

Just sign the ticket and move along. 

So, how have courts viewed tailgating?  Turns out, not well for the tailgater.

Bexar County, Texas – Manslaughter from Tailgating and Reckless Driving (2025)

  • A jury convicted a driver for manslaughter following a fatal motorcycle crash near San Antonio, centered on tailgating, speeding, and passing in a no-passing zone. The defendant received a 10-year sentence, plus a concurrent 3-year term for carrying a weapon.

  • Relevance: Demonstrates how tailgating combined with other dangerous behaviors can elevate charges to serious crimes—even unintentionally causing death.

Roux v. Coffey, Docket #AC46898 (2025)

  • Case summary: A Connecticut appellate court ruled in January 2025 that Live Nation, the concert promoter, was not liable for the death of a 17-year-old, Luke Roux, who was killed by a driver (Jacob Coffey) who had tailgated outside the Xfinity Theater after drinking and then ran a red light. The court determined that property owners don’t generally bear liability for individuals who consume alcohol on their property and later drive and cause harm.

  • Significance: The case underscores legal boundaries on premises liability when alcohol and tailgating precede a DUI crash.

Fassett v. Santiam Loggers, Inc., 267 Or. 505, 517 P.2d 1059 (1973) – Truck rear-ended a car after following too closely. Court held that violation of Oregon’s tailgating statute constituted negligence per se, making the trucking company liable.

Harris v. Harman, 253 Va. 336, 486 S.E.2d 99 (1997)

  • Court: Virginia Supreme Court

  • Issue: Whether tailgating contributed to the plaintiff's accident.

  • Outcome: The court found that Harris had been tailgating Harman for a considerable period, which distracted Harman. The jury had to determine if this tailgating was the cause of the accident. This case highlights how tailgating can be a factor in determining negligence.

Garnot v. Johnson, 239 Va. 81, 387 S.E.2d 473 (1990)

  • Court: Virginia Supreme Court

  • Issue: Whether the rear driver's tailgating was the proximate cause of the rear-end collision.

  • Outcome: The court concluded that the plaintiff was entitled to an instruction on following too closely, emphasizing the rear driver's responsibility in maintaining a safe distance.

Meeks v. Hodges, 226 Va. 106, 306 S.E.2d 879 (1983)

  • Court: Virginia Supreme Court

  • Issue: Whether the rear driver was following too closely, leading to the accident.

  • Outcome: The court found that there was a jury question as to whether the rear driver was following too closely, which contributed to the accident.

Bottom line:  Slow down, back off and pay attention to the conditions of the road.  If you think you're too close or the driver in front of you suddenly taps their breaks and you're having to smash the brakes to avoid an accident, you probably are too close.  
 
So, back the @#%# off my bumper!